Comparison · AMSOIL Max-Duty vs Petro-Canada Duron

AMSOIL vs Petro-Canada Duron: Heavy-Duty Diesel Oil Compared

AMSOIL vs Petro-Canada Duron comes down to which tier you compare. Duron-E was Petro-Canada's CJ-4-era oil. Since late 2016 the line has been Duron HP, SHP and UHP (CK-4) plus Duron Advanced (FA-4). AMSOIL Signature Series Max-Duty lines up against Duron UHP, Petro-Canada's full-synthetic tier.

Last reviewed: November 2026 · Based on Petro-Canada Lubricants' Duron product-line release (2016), its Cummins and Detroit Diesel OEM approval brochures (2023), the Duron UHP 10W-30 launch (2025), and AMSOIL data sheets G3467 and G3468

Both brands make full-synthetic API CK-4 diesel oils that meet Cummins CES 20086 and Detroit DFS 93K222. The differences: Petro-Canada sells an FA-4 oil (Duron Advanced) and AMSOIL does not. AMSOIL publishes its drain limit and test results: Max-Duty is rated for up to three times the OEM interval, not to exceed 60,000 miles, 600 hours or one year. It shows 6X more wear protection than required in the Detroit DD13 scuffing test for DFS 93K222. Petro-Canada says Duron supports extended drains but gives no figure. If you run a CK-4 engine and want a documented extended drain, the Red Seal tech pick is AMSOIL Max-Duty 15W-40 (DME).

CK-4
Both brands
full synthetic
60,000 mi
AMSOIL max drain
3X OEM cap

6X
AMSOIL wear result
DD13 scuffing test
FA-4
Petro-Canada only
Duron Advanced

Duron-E
Petro-Canada's CJ-4-era line · current Duron range launched Dec 2016
The Lineups

Petro-Canada Duron Lineup vs AMSOIL

Petro-Canada split Duron into tiers when CK-4 and FA-4 arrived. Here's where each one sits next to AMSOIL's heavy-duty diesel oils.

Petro-CanadaClosest AMSOIL
Duron-E
CJ-4, older line
Replaced by today's CK-4 oils
Duron HP / SHP
CK-4
Heavy-Duty Synthetic (ADP, ADN) or Commercial-Grade (SBDF, SBDT)
Duron UHP
CK-4, full synthetic
Signature Series Max-Duty (DME, DTT, DEO)
Duron Advanced
FA-4
No AMSOIL FA-4 oil

Still have Duron-E on the shelf? It was a CJ-4 oil. Today's CK-4 oils replace it and are backward compatible, so you can switch to any of the CK-4 oils above.

Head to Head

AMSOIL Max-Duty vs Duron UHP

Both are full-synthetic CK-4 oils with Cummins and Detroit coverage. The gap is in what each brand publishes.

AMSOIL Max-DutyDuron UHP
API
CK-4CK-4
Cummins CES 20086
Meets requirementsApproved
Detroit DFS 93K222
Meets requirementsApproved
Drain limit
3X OEM, max 60,000 mi / 600 hr / 1 yr"Extending drain intervals", no figure
Wear result
6X more than DFS 93K222 requires (DD13 scuffing test)No equivalent figure published
Grades
15W-40, 10W-30, 5W-40, 0W-40, 5W-3010W-40, 10W-30, 5W-40, 5W-30

Sources: Petro-Canada's 2023 Cummins and Detroit Diesel approval brochures and its Duron UHP 10W-30 launch. AMSOIL figures from data sheet G3467. AMSOIL's wear result uses a 10W-30 as the worst case.

"Meets" vs "Approved": "Approved" means the oil is on the engine maker's own list. "Meets the requirements of" means the oil maker states it passes that spec's tests. AMSOIL's data sheets list the specs its oils are made for, and AMSOIL backs them with its own warranty. What the difference means for you →

Honest Assessment

When Each One Makes Sense

Pick the oil that matches your engine and how you run it.

Your situationBetter fit
Engine manual lists FA-4 and you want itPetro-Canada Duron Advanced
You want a documented extended drainAMSOIL Max-Duty, with oil analysis
You're staying on the OEM intervalEither; AMSOIL ADP or Commercial-Grade SBDF, or Duron HP/SHP
Mixed fleet, old and new enginesA CK-4 that lists every spec in the yard

⚠ Going past the OEM interval: AMSOIL backs its 3X drain with oil analysis. Without a lab report on your own trucks, stay on the engine maker's schedule whichever brand you run.

Get an Oil Analysis Kit →
Recommended Products

AMSOIL Oils to Compare With Duron

Each of these meets the requirements of Cummins CES 20086, Detroit DFS 93K222, Volvo VDS-4.5 and Mack EOS-4.5, per G3467, G3468 and G3793.

vs Duron HP / SHP
AMSOIL Heavy-Duty Synthetic
15W-40 · ADP · API CK-4
  • Made to run OEM drain intervals
  • Full synthetic heavy-duty diesel oil
  • Extend past OEM only with oil analysis
  • A fit for fleets on the OEM schedule
Shop ADP 15W-40 →
OEM Intervals · Blend
AMSOIL Commercial-Grade
15W-40 · SBDF · API CK-4
  • Synthetic blend, over 50% synthetic
  • 2X more wear protection than DFS 93K222 requires
  • Made to run OEM drain intervals
  • Also in 10W-30 (SBDT)
Shop SBDF 15W-40 →

Running a 10W-30 engine? Shop Max-Duty 10W-30 (DTT) → Full synthetic, also meets Ford WSS-M2C171-F1.

Own your truck or run a fleet? One truck under your own authority qualifies. Accounts are set up through Vyscocity Inc., an Independent AMSOIL Dealer.Open a Commercial Account →
FAQ

AMSOIL vs Petro-Canada Duron FAQ

Is Petro-Canada Duron-E still sold?

Duron-E was Petro-Canada's CJ-4-era line. When API CK-4 and FA-4 arrived in December 2016, Petro-Canada launched Duron HP, SHP, UHP and Advanced. Today's CK-4 oils replace CJ-4 and are backward compatible.

Which Duron oil compares to AMSOIL Max-Duty?

Duron UHP, Petro-Canada's full-synthetic CK-4 tier. Both carry Cummins CES 20086 and Detroit DFS 93K222 coverage.

Does Petro-Canada make an FA-4 oil?

Yes, Duron Advanced, in 10W-30 and 5W-30, approved for Cummins CES 20087 and Detroit DFS 93K223. AMSOIL does not make an FA-4 oil.

How long can AMSOIL Max-Duty run between changes?

AMSOIL rates it for up to three times the OEM interval in heavy-duty service, not to exceed 60,000 miles, 600 hours or one year. Use oil analysis to confirm.

Can I mix AMSOIL and Petro-Canada Duron?

AMSOIL says its diesel oils are compatible with other oils, but mixing shortens oil life, and AMSOIL doesn't support extended drains on mixed oil. Do a full change when you switch.

Scroll to Top