Comparisons · Shell · Mobil · Castrol · Petro-Canada

Diesel Oil Comparisons for Semi Trucks: AMSOIL vs the Big Brands

These diesel oil comparisons put AMSOIL next to the oils Class 8 fleets and owner-operators actually buy: Shell Rotella, Mobil Delvac, Castrol Vecton and Petro-Canada Duron. Every number comes from each brand's own data sheet, and every page shows where the other brand comes out ahead.

Last reviewed: November 2026 · Comparisons are built from each brand's published product data sheets and AMSOIL data sheets G3793, G3468, G3467 and G473

AMSOIL makes three heavy-duty diesel oil levels, so each comparison matches the right one to the other brand's oil. Commercial-Grade is a synthetic blend that runs the OEM interval. Heavy-Duty is a full synthetic that runs the OEM interval. Max-Duty is a full synthetic rated up to 3X the OEM drain, max 60,000 miles, with oil analysis. Against DFS 93K222's wear limit, AMSOIL publishes 2X, 4X and 6X more protection for the three levels. The other brands usually carry formal OEM approvals; AMSOIL lists the specs its oils meet the requirements of. Red Seal tech pick: AMSOIL Max-Duty 15W-40 (DME) for most Class 8 trucks.

3
AMSOIL heavy-duty
levels compared
10
Comparison
pages

2X · 4X · 6X
AMSOIL wear results
by level
4
Competitor
brands

Data sheets only
No invented tests, no sponsored rankings
Quick Match

Which AMSOIL Oil Matches Yours

The AMSOIL level each comparison page matches to the other brand's oil. Click an oil for the full numbers.

You run nowAMSOIL match
Shell Rotella T6 15W-40Heavy-Duty or Max-Duty
Mobil Delvac 1300 SuperCommercial-Grade
Mobil Delvac ExtremeMax-Duty
Mobil Delvac 1 ESP 5W-40Heavy-Duty (ADO) or Max-Duty (DEO)
Mobil Delvac MX F2 (older, no DPF)AME 15W-40
Castrol Vecton 15W-40Max-Duty
Petro-Canada DuronHeavy-Duty or Max-Duty

AMSOIL's own diesel oil comparison chart (NP102) lists Max-Duty as a replacement for any Shell Rotella, Heavy-Duty for Rotella T6 and Commercial-Grade for Rotella T5, T4 and T3.

Method

How These Comparisons Are Built

Same rules on every page, so you can trust the numbers whichever way they point.

RuleWhat it means
Data sheets onlyEvery number comes from the brand's current published data sheet, linked in each page's sources.
Same tests side by sideHTHS, TBN, cold cranking, pour point and drain claims, where both brands publish them.
Right level, right oilA synthetic blend is compared to a synthetic blend, a 5W-40 to a 5W-40.
Wins both waysWhere the other brand has formal approvals, a higher number or a longer drain claim, the page says so.
Region checkedUS and Canadian data sheets first; oils sold mainly overseas are labelled that way.

"Meets" vs "Approved": "Approved" means the oil is on the engine maker's own list. "Meets the requirements of" means the oil maker states it passes that spec's tests. AMSOIL's data sheets list the specs its oils are made for, and AMSOIL backs them with its own warranty. What the difference means for you →

Recommended Products

The Three AMSOIL Heavy-Duty Levels

Each meets the requirements of Cummins CES 20086, Detroit DFS 93K222, Volvo VDS-4.5 and Mack EOS-4.5, per G3793, G3468 and G3467.

Heavy-Duty
AMSOIL Heavy-Duty Synthetic
15W-40 · ADP · API CK-4
  • Full synthetic
  • 4X more wear protection than DFS 93K222 requires
  • Made to run OEM drain intervals
  • Also in 10W-30 and 5W-40
Shop ADP 15W-40 →
Commercial-Grade
AMSOIL Commercial-Grade
15W-40 · SBDF · API CK-4
  • Synthetic blend, over 50% synthetic
  • 2X more wear protection than DFS 93K222 requires
  • Made to run OEM drain intervals
  • Also in 10W-30 (SBDT)
Shop SBDF 15W-40 →
Own your truck or run a fleet? One truck under your own authority qualifies. Accounts are set up through Vyscocity Inc., an Independent AMSOIL Dealer.Open a Commercial Account →
FAQ

Diesel Oil Comparison FAQ

Which AMSOIL diesel oil should I compare to my current oil?

Match the level. Compare a synthetic blend such as Delvac 1300 Super to AMSOIL Commercial-Grade, a full synthetic at the OEM interval to Heavy-Duty, and an extended-drain synthetic such as Delvac Extreme to Max-Duty.

Why doesn't AMSOIL list OEM approvals like Shell and Mobil?

Getting on an approval list means paying fees and handing over the formula, which then stops being proprietary. AMSOIL formulates its oils to meet the requirements of the specs instead and backs them with its own warranty.

Does switching to AMSOIL void my engine warranty?

Choosing another brand of oil does not by itself void an engine warranty, as long as the oil meets the spec your engine maker calls for. The AMSOIL guarantee, explained.

Can I mix AMSOIL with Rotella or Delvac?

AMSOIL says its diesel oils are compatible with other oils, but mixing shortens oil life, and AMSOIL doesn't support extended drains on mixed oil. Do a full change when you switch.

Can I run extended drains right away?

Of the three levels, only AMSOIL Max-Duty is rated for extended drains, up to 3X OEM, and AMSOIL backs that with oil analysis. Start on the engine maker's interval and stretch it as lab reports on your own trucks allow.

Scroll to Top